With the globalization of the auction houses, mega-galleries and art fairs over the past two decades, wealth has become increasingly international – and taste has globalized with it. At the same time, there is a growing population of wealthy individuals around the world with the means to collect art, well beneath the headline-grabbing world of billionaire trophy purchases. Yet true connoisseurship can sometimes feel harder to find. The challenge for the art world today may not simply be to find new buyers, but to turn those buyers into collectors.
Text by Jo Vickery
Two articles published recently in The Art Newspaper touched on this question from rather different angles: Anny Shaw’s “The art world’s billionaire problem is getting worse”, based on a long-term look at art-market trends, and Scott Reyburn’s “From Poussin to Pokémon: why attitudes towards collecting art are shifting”.
Reyburn invokes the idea of a second Gilded Age. The original Gilded Age, born out of the industrialization of the United States in the late nineteenth century, created enormous new fortunes and helped propel an extraordinary movement of works of art from old European collections across the Atlantic. American collectors such as Henry Clay Frick, J. P. Morgan, Isabella Stewart Gardner and Peter Widener gradually assembled collections that would ultimately help transform the cultural landscape of the United States.
Today we are experiencing a different sort of generational shift. Rather than European aristocratic families necessarily being forced to sell, some of the great collections assembled over the past half-century are now returning to the market as collectors die and estates are dispersed. A steady succession of fabled collections has produced spectacular auction results. Their greatest works continue to break records and can give the impression of an art market in rude health.
There has always been an element of this in the auction world. A single top lot could make or break an evening sale. What is perhaps different today is the degree to which an increasingly large proportion of value can be concentrated in a remarkably small number of objects and buyers.
Further down the market, however, the picture is more complicated.
Reyburn sounds the alarm over changing tastes, with younger collectors potentially preferring Pokémon to Poussin. To some extent, this is not new. Taste is always changing. What does seem significant is the prolonged decline of entire areas that once supported substantial and knowledgeable communities of collectors.
As an art adviser who has watched the market over several decades, I have seen whole swathes of what was once highly collectible fall dramatically out of fashion, particularly nineteenth-century European and Victorian painting. I am not referring here to the much more recent boom and bust in so-called red-chip contemporary art. This is a longer and deeper erosion of collecting categories that once had established audiences.
The closure of Christie’s South Kensington in 2017 felt symbolic of this change. CSK was a legendary place where more than one art adviser began a career. It was somewhere to spend hours snuffling around looking at pictures and objects, learning by looking, and occasionally discovering something overlooked or under-catalogued – the elusive “sleeper”. It belonged to a broader collecting culture in which people were prepared to explore unfamiliar names and categories rather than concentrating exclusively on established trophy artists.
Yet this is not necessarily a story of economic decline.
We are living in an era of enormous wealth inequality, but several studies show that wealth creation is not confined to billionaires. The number of millionaires and ultra-high-net-worth individuals has also expanded substantially around the world. In other words, the potential collector base is growing at precisely the moment when some traditional collecting fields are contracting.
So where are the collectors?
The evolution of the two great auction houses, Sotheby’s and Christie’s, into sellers not only of fine art but of watches, jewellery, handbags, cars, wine and other luxury goods has accelerated over recent years. This is perfectly understandable: the auction houses are responding to where demand lies and, in doing so, reaching an enormous new audience of wealthy consumers.
But it raises another question. If a new client enters an auction house through a watch, a handbag or a piece of jewellery, what encourages that person eventually to become interested in a drawing, a rare book, an eighteenth-century object or an Old Master painting?
There is an important distinction between creating customers and creating collectors.
The great collectors of the first Gilded Age were not necessarily born connoisseurs, nor did they begin by buying masterpieces. Many developed their collections gradually over decades. They travelled, looked, listened to dealers and scholars, occasionally made mistakes and refined their taste. Frick began with relatively modest purchases before moving towards the Old Masters that now define his collection. Gardner collected books and manuscripts before competing for great Renaissance and Dutch paintings. Widener bought, learned, reconsidered and upgraded.
Their advisers and dealers played an important part in that education.
Art fairs can still offer something of this experience today. The best fairs allow us to encounter objects we were not looking for. In Europe, TEFAF and Frieze Masters remain particularly exciting because they bring together fine and decorative arts from many different periods. You can arrive thinking about paintings and unexpectedly find yourself looking at a medieval manuscript, a Renaissance bronze, a piece of eighteenth-century furniture or a rare book.
Just as importantly, many of the exhibitors are established specialists who have spent decades developing expertise in their fields. Some have built their businesses largely through their own connoisseurship and wits: small galleries rather than global corporations, where accumulated knowledge can extend across generations.
This kind of encounter matters because the challenge is not to resist a global art market, but to prevent a global art market from becoming a homogeneous one.
Today collectors in New York, London, Paris, Hong Kong, Dubai or Seoul increasingly encounter the same artists, galleries, auction houses and fairs. This internationalization has brought many benefits, but it can also encourage a narrowing of taste, particularly when market data constantly reinforces what is already successful.
Technology may make this tendency stronger. Algorithms and, increasingly, artificial intelligence are exceptionally good at learning what we already appear to like and offering us more of it. Connoisseurship often develops in precisely the opposite way: through encountering something that we did not know we liked.
Algorithms refine preference; connoisseurship expands it.
As art professionals, we therefore have some responsibility to educate our clients into collectors rather than simply customers. That means transmitting the pleasure of looking at objects and understanding them, and encouraging curiosity beyond the obvious names. Value cannot be understood solely through market data. It can also lie in recognising the quality of a sketch, understanding why a drawing matters, opening a rare book and delighting in its pages, or discovering a beautiful portrait by an artist who is slipping into obscurity.
These less fashionable areas of the market matter because they reveal something about the maturity of a collecting culture. The Old Master market demonstrates the problem particularly clearly. Demand has become heavily concentrated around a small group of major names, where exceptional works can command extraordinary prices, while many highly accomplished but less celebrated artists struggle to attract the collectors they once did.
The health of an art market cannot therefore be measured only by the prices achieved for its greatest masterpieces. It can also be measured by the curiosity of its collectors: whether someone is prepared to stop in front of an unfamiliar drawing, pick up a rare book, learn about a forgotten painter or develop enough confidence in an unfashionable field to recognise quality for themselves.
The Age of Global Wealth has created no shortage of potential buyers. The more important task for the art world is to create collectors.




