Skip to main content

Paintings are constantly changing, as pigments fade, varnishes yellow and materials react to light, humidity and time. Drawing on both her postgraduate studies and current work in art authentication, Angie Afifi explores how these physical transformations can alter not only the colours we see, but sometimes our understanding of the works themselves.

Text by Angie Afifi

When we stand before a painting, it is natural to assume that we are seeing it much as the artist intended. Yet a painting is not a static image. It is a physical object composed of a wide range of materials, including pigments, binding media, varnishes, and its support. All of these materials respond differently to light, humidity, and other environmental factors, gradually changing over time.

Some colour changes in paintings are gradual and almost impossible to observe from one generation to the next. Over decades or centuries, however, pigments may fade, darken or become more transparent. Varnishes can yellow, delicate details may disappear, and the relationship between different colours can shift. As a result, the appearance of a painting today may differ significantly from the one originally seen in the artist’s studio.

One of the most common misconceptions is that old paintings simply become darker. In reality, the ageing process is far more complex. Different pigments behave in different ways: some lose their intensity, others change colour, while certain paint layers become increasingly transparent. These transformations do not affect every part of a painting equally. A stable pigment may retain much of its original appearance while the colour beside it changes considerably, altering the visual balance of the whole composition.

A remarkable example is Johannes Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring. Today, the figure appears against an almost entirely black background, creating the impression that she is emerging from an undefined darkness. Technical examination conducted by the Mauritshuis has shown, however, that Vermeer originally placed her in front of a dark green curtain. Diagonal lines and variations in colour revealed the folds of the fabric, but physical and chemical changes in the translucent green paint have caused the curtain to become almost invisible. The same research identified tiny hairs around the eyes, showing that Vermeer had also painted delicate eyelashes that can no longer be clearly seen with the naked eye.

Such discoveries subtly change our understanding of the painting. The work has not simply become darker: part of its setting has disappeared, and the relationship between the figure and her surroundings is no longer the same. What now appears to be an abstract dark space originally contained a recognisable, if discreetly painted, element of fabric.

Evidence of colour change can also be found in an unexpected place: the palettes represented in seventeenth-century Dutch self-portraits. Artists often depicted themselves holding the tools of their profession, including palettes covered with small areas of paint. Today, many of these painted palettes appear dominated by blacks, browns and muted reddish or yellowish tones. Yet they have undergone the same ageing processes as the rest of the painted surface. They therefore offer a striking reminder that the colours we now see in historic paintings are not necessarily identical to those that first appeared on the artist’s palette.

The effects of ageing are not limited to the loss of bright colour. Changes in the transparency and optical properties of paint can also transform the way light, space and form are perceived. In paintings associated with Rembrandt, areas that now seem almost completely submerged in darkness may originally have contained more visible detail. When paint layers become more transparent or alter chemically, figures and architectural elements can recede, while other parts of the composition become unexpectedly prominent. The result may influence not only what we see, but also how we interpret the artist’s use of light and shadow.

Natural varnishes add another layer to this changing history. Traditionally applied to protect the painted surface and increase the depth and saturation of colour, many varnishes gradually acquire a yellow or amber tone. This can make a painting appear warmer, darker and more uniform than it once did. The careful removal of discoloured varnish during conservation may reveal cooler colours and more subtle tonal relationships that have remained hidden for generations.

However, conservation cannot simply return a painting to the moment when the artist put down the brush. The original materials themselves may already have changed, and some losses are irreversible. Conservators must therefore distinguish between an altered surface coating that can be removed and changes that have taken place within the paint itself. Their task is not to recreate a hypothetical original image, but to preserve the work responsibly while making its surviving qualities as legible as possible.

Nor is colour change confined to paintings by the Old Masters. The expansion of the artists’ colour market during the nineteenth century introduced brilliant new synthetic pigments, but some proved less stable than their appearance initially suggested.

This process has been particularly well studied in Vincent van Gogh’s Sunflowers. Research on the version of the painting housed at the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam has shown that Van Gogh used several varieties of chrome yellow pigment, creating a complex system of closely related yet distinct shades. However, these pigments do not age in the same way: some remain relatively stable, while others gradually darken or shift towards an olive-brown hue. As a result, not only do the colours themselves change, but so do their relationships within the composition—the very colour contrasts through which Van Gogh created volume, light, and expressive power.

This is especially significant in the case of Van Gogh, for whom colour was not merely descriptive but central to the emotional and structural power of a painting. He relied on colour as one of his principal means of artistic expression. Even a subtle alteration in a single shade of yellow can therefore disrupt the original balance between the flowers, the background, the green stems, and the orange details. Although scientific research cannot fully reconstruct Van Gogh’s original palette, it enables conservators to identify the most vulnerable areas of the painting and develop strategies to slow further deterioration of the paint layers.

A similar problem affects Edvard Munch’s The Scream. Research on the version dating from around 1910 has shown that some areas painted with cadmium yellow have faded, turned off-white or begun to flake. Investigations found that humidity, rather than light alone, plays a major role in the deterioration of these particular yellow paints. This discovery has practical consequences for the conditions in which the painting can safely be stored and displayed.

Munch’s example demonstrates that a painting can change substantially within little more than a century. Modern works may feel materially closer to us than seventeenth-century paintings, yet many nineteenth- and twentieth-century artists experimented with newly manufactured colours whose long-term behaviour was not fully understood. Their technical freedom produced extraordinary visual effects, but it also created new conservation challenges.

The examples discussed here are only a small glimpse of the many changes that works of art undergo over time. Every painting ages differently, as its materials respond in their own way to light, humidity, and the surrounding environment. These processes remind us of one important fact: the colours we see today are not always the colours the artist originally painted.

Understanding these changes helps us better appreciate both the materials artists worked with and the challenges of preserving their paintings. It also reminds us that every historic painting has changed, at least to some extent, since it was first created. What we see today is shaped not only by the artist’s intention, but also by chemistry, the environment, conservation, and time.

Every painting therefore carries two intertwined histories: the story created by the artist and another written by the material life of the work itself.

Image: Vincent van Gogh, Sunflowers, 1889, oil on canvas, 95 by 73cm. Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam (Vincent van Gogh Foundation), inv. no. S0031V1962. Public domain.